Logical Fallacies 05 Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc episode 286

Logical Fallacies 05 Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc episode 286 mp3logical fallacy post hoc ergo propter hoc

Post hoc ergo propter hoc is Latin for, ”after this therefore because of this”.

“the logical fallacy of believing that temporal succession implies a causal relation” Dictionary.com

This fallacy takes place when a person comes to a conclusion based solely on a proceeding event.  In other words one might conclude that a rooster crowing causes the sun to rise simply because the sun rises after the rooster crows.

Example of post hoc ergo propter hoc

I might notice that every time I get into a checkout line at the supermarket, the line takes longer than all the other lines.  Should I conclude that my mere presence in the line causes the checker to move slower?  No.  Perhaps I am a poor judge of which line is the fastest.  Either way, if you see me in a checkout line, you would be safe to pick a different line to stand in.

It’s important to mention that just because someone uses this fallacy in an argument does not immediately mean their conclusion is false.  It simply means the burden is on them to provide more convincing reasoning if they want you to be persuaded.

Disarming the post hoc ergo propter hoc

Some might be wondering how one is to refute or deal with a post hoc ergo propter hoc argument.  It’s pretty simple

  1. Point out the fallacy – Sometimes this step is offensive.  Use some tact.  They need to realize that there conclusion doesn’t necessarily follow from whatever proceeding event they are citing.
  2. Point out another conclusion that could be reached -   In my example, I mentioned that every checkout line I stand in goes slow.   By utilizing the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, I concluded that my mere presence in a checkout line causes the line to move slower (I still think that’s true).  What other reasons could there be for this strange phenomenon?  Could it be that I stink at selecting a fast line?  Could it be that the checker is distracted by my stunning good looks?  Could it be that I have waited too long between showers and a curious aroma is distracting my checker?  All of these options are viable…ok, one of them is.  Nonetheless, our friend committing the fallacy should be aware that other solutions or conclusions are available.
  3. Let them have the burden of proof – Let the person who is committing the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy know that there argument is not convincing.  It is their job to support their argument with something more persuasive then the after this therefore because of this fallacy.

Here are other logical fallacy podcast mp3s ready for download.

Logical Fallacies-Ad Hominem mp3

Logical Fallacies-Analogical Fallacy mp3

Logical Fallacies-Equivocation mp3

Logical Fallacies-Genetic Fallacy mp3

Or check out the Youth Apologetics Training Podcast Archive.


{ 2 comments… add one }

  • prefabricated house kits June 27, 2015, 10:44 pm

    Micron designs and builds advanced memory and semiconductor technologies including dynamic random access memory products (DRAM). Micron has recently solidified its position as a major supplier to Apple through its purchase of Elpida Memory, a DRAM supplier to the smartphone and tablet market. Elpida chips can be found in Apple’s products including the iPhone 5c..
    prefabricated house kits http://www.hbbfhouse.com

  • beyond yoga June 23, 2015, 12:29 am

    The most obvious way to make money from Y2K was to write a terrible book in the late nineties about how to survive Y2K. The main problem I had with this one is that it wasn’t even published until well into 1999. Assuming you read this the day it came out and put together a business plan and found investors the next day, you’d maybe be up and running for a week before your company’s computers tore you apart for their Y2K Robosports.
    beyond yoga http://yogawearforsale.com


Leave a Comment


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers